Guides

How working memory and long-term memory shape learning differences

How working memory and long-term memory shape learning differences

How working memory and long-term memory shape learning differences

Why some pupils “know it but can’t show it”: what working memory does in reading and writing, and simple ways to ease the load in class.

Why some pupils “know it but can’t show it”: what working memory does in reading and writing, and simple ways to ease the load in class.

By

By

Leo Thornton

,

Chief Product Officer

·

Illustration: a visible story-writing sequence, ‘Say it’, ‘Write it’, ‘Check it’, with the first two steps ticked, beside a Talamo report card: How to support, ‘Break tasks into a short visible sequence’ (Adjustment, In the classroom).
A visible story-writing sequence, ‘Say it’, ‘Write it’, ‘Check it’, with the first two steps ticked, above a Talamo report card: How to support, ‘Break tasks into a short visible sequence’ (Adjustment, In the classroom).

Almost every lesson asks pupils to hold something in mind while they use it: an instruction while they start a task, the beginning of a sentence while they read the end, a number while they add the next column. Two memory systems do most of that work. When they don’t work smoothly together, a pupil can understand a topic well and still struggle to show it.

What working memory does

Working memory is the small mental workspace we use to hold and work with information for a few seconds. Psychologists often describe it, following Alan Baddeley’s model, as a system that briefly holds sounds and words, holds images and spatial information, and directs attention between them.

Everyone’s working memory has limits, but capacity varies a lot between pupils of the same age. In reading and writing, working memory helps a pupil:

  • keep sounds in order while they blend them into a word

  • remember the start of a sentence long enough to make sense of the end

  • hold an idea while they work out how to spell it

  • follow an instruction with more than one step

What long-term memory does

Long-term memory stores what has been learned: phonics patterns, spellings, vocabulary, number facts, routines and strategies. When that knowledge is secure and quick to retrieve, it takes almost no effort to use, which leaves working memory free for the new and difficult part of a task.

That’s why fluency matters. A pupil who has to work out every word from scratch is using their working memory to decode, with little left over for meaning.

When the two don’t work smoothly

Many teachers will recognise the pattern of a pupil who “knows it but can’t show it”:

  • they contribute well in discussion, but their writing stalls after a sentence or two

  • they follow the first step of an instruction, then lose the rest

  • they read a sentence accurately, but can’t say what it meant

  • they spell a word correctly in a test, but not in a longer piece of writing

These moments are often signs of overload rather than low ability or poor effort. The task is asking the pupil to hold more at once than their working memory comfortably allows.

Working memory and dyslexia

Research has linked dyslexia with working memory difficulties for a long time. In one study, 22 adult students with dyslexia were compared with 22 matched peers: the dyslexic group had lower scores on all the verbal working memory tasks, and on a spatial task that combined storing and processing information. The authors concluded that working memory difficulties in dyslexia can extend into adulthood.

But working memory doesn’t follow labels neatly. A 2019 study of 302 seven- and eight-year-olds found four distinct working memory profiles, and children with dyslexia, children with developmental language disorder and typically developing children appeared in every one of them. Lower working memory is also common with attention difficulties. So a working memory score is most useful alongside a pupil’s other results, not as a verdict on its own.

That’s how Talamo treats it. Working memory is one of the key indicators our Cognitive & Dyslexia assessment measures: pupils hear a string of numbers and type them backwards. It’s reported next to phonological awareness, processing speed, verbal and visual reasoning, reading and spelling, so staff can see whether a difficulty looks like a gap in knowledge or a pupil trying to hold too much at once.

Ways to reduce the load in class

You can’t make a pupil’s working memory bigger, but you can make tasks ask less of it. These suggestions come from the “How to support” sections of Talamo reports:

  • Break tasks into a short, visible sequence. Show two or three steps on the board or a mini whiteboard, using simple words and pictures. For story writing, try “say it, write it, check it”, and let the pupil tick off each part.

  • Keep instructions visible. Pause after a harder question and leave it on the board while the pupil thinks.

  • Record key ideas with pictures and short notes. A quick sketch, a story map or two or three key words can hold ideas so the pupil doesn’t have to.

  • Teach how to take useful notes. Older pupils benefit from being shown what is worth recording, for example with a two-column outline or a mind map, rather than trying to write everything down.

  • Pre-teach key vocabulary. Words that are already familiar are quicker to retrieve, which leaves more room for the new content.

  • Build in spaced review. Revisit key spellings and facts after a few days and again the following week, so they move from effortful to automatic.

A clearer picture helps

Memory differences are common, and they can easily be mistaken for inattention or a lack of effort. A standardised profile helps staff see what’s really going on and plan support that fits, rather than repeating work a pupil already understands. See how working memory appears in a sample Talamo report.

Sources

Sources

Sources

See what Talamo would show you about your pupils

See what Talamo would show you about your pupils

See what Talamo would show you about your pupils

Book a short call with our team. We’ll walk you through a sample report and answer your questions about screening in your school.

Book a short call with our team. We’ll walk you through a sample report and answer your questions about screening in your school.

Talamo

Designed for parents and teachers to spot learning patterns early and clearly.

Get updates from Talamo

A monthly email with news, research and event updates for SENCos, schools and families.

© Talamo Limited 2026. Registered in England and Wales, company number 13714418. Registered office: 3 Buckland House, William Prance Road, Plymouth PL6 5WR.

Talamo

Designed for parents and teachers to spot learning patterns early and clearly.

Get updates from Talamo

A monthly email with news, research and event updates for SENCos, schools and families.

© Talamo Limited 2026. Registered in England and Wales, company number 13714418. Registered office: 3 Buckland House, William Prance Road, Plymouth PL6 5WR.

Talamo

Designed for parents and teachers to spot learning patterns early and clearly.

Get updates from Talamo

A monthly email with news, research and event updates for SENCos, schools and families.

© Talamo Limited 2026. Registered in England and Wales, company number 13714418. Registered office: 3 Buckland House, William Prance Road, Plymouth PL6 5WR.